As the Helio turns

Posted by Iannucci | 3/12/2009 | 9 comments »
Bookmark and Share

After a few more days of testimony, we might finally have resolved the issue where this whole idea of Helio becoming the newest resident of Monaco arose.

Kevin Savoree, now an executive at Andretti Green Racing, said when he handled accounting work for Castroneves in 1999 and 2000, the plan was to set up a legitimate deal in which much of the two-time Indianapolis 500 winner's income would be deferred. That meant his taxes owed to the IRS also would be deferred until he actually got the money.

"Helio Castroneves never suggested that you do something improper, right?" asked Castroneves attorney David Garvin.

"Absolutely not," Savoree replied.

But Savoree acknowledged helping draft a memo describing the ultimate goal as having Castroneves "maintain a residence in a tax haven, such as Monaco." Castroneves, a Brazilian citizen in the U.S. on a work visa, currently lives in Coral Gables, Fla., just south of Miami.

(MORE from Associated Press)
So in 1999 Helio talked about moving to Monaco. He's a citizen of Brazil, he currently resides in Florida, but 10 years ago he talked about moving to Monaco. OK then.

Yes, auto racing celebrities often move overseas to minimize their tax liability, but Helio isn't one of them. At least not yet he isn't, and last I checked you can't be tried for something you didn't do. This is like trying him for not paying taxes that aren't due until this May ... oh wait, that's also what the prosecution is doing.

Now before anyone starts exonerating Helio, remember the trial still has many weeks ahead. I've been told by one lawyer that this will probably last into May, which would effectively end Helio's season before it starts. We also have to endure more testimony regarding this concept of "constructive receipt" which determines if an individual has to pay taxes immediately or can defer them if payment is also deferred.

Helio might have an ace in the hole in this area, though, according to SI.com.

Bolstering this defense is that other drivers, including Eliot Sadler of Sprint Cup, have complained about convoluted verbiage found in racing contracts. Keep in mind, if the jury concludes that Castroneves lacked financial understanding, he would be poised to escape conviction: tax evasion requires the prosecution to prove that Castroneves willfully evaded taxes; if he was unaware that certain payments must be treated as taxable income, then he could not have committed tax evasion.
Which is great for Helio, but there's always the possibility that he is acquitted of tax evasion but convicted on charges relating to false testimony.

Lots of trial days ahead folks, but from what I can tell there's been no proverbial silver bullet yet revealed by the prosecution. But that's just one word butcher's opinion - if you see it differently please share.

More Twits, err, Tweets to follow

Posted by Iannucci | 3/12/2009 | 2 comments »
Bookmark and Share

The twitter universe continues to grow, passing along information at a nearly instantaneous pace. Of course, much of this information involves people telling you what they're eating or watching on TV, but it's a new medium and the kinks are still being worked out.

If you're using twitter, here are three more suggestions for you to follow.

@DRRinIndyCar - the official account of Dreyer & Reinbold Racing, who may or may not actually have a car shown on the air during a race this year.

@maxpapis - the driver of IndyCars and all other things four-wheeled is CONSTANTLY tweeting and forwarding pictures of the many racing series in which he participates. This guy is a reality show waiting to happen.

@curtcavin - yes, the intrepid one is now all a-twitter, sending updates even as he watches N-word racing. I'm certain your viewing will be enhanced.

Speaking of Cavin, he provided a tiny update on the much discussed Ryan Hunter-Reay. Ryan said he's currently talking with two teams: one is HVM Racing, the other is NOT Rahal Letterman Racing (which makes sense since there's no longer any mention of IndyCars at the Rahal site).

Meetings are planned for later this week and next.

"Nothing is imminent," he said today. "But it seems like progress."
Perhaps more will be discussed between Curt and Ryan as they talk in your ear tonight on the TrackSide program at 1070 The Fan.

The Hunter-Reay conundrum

Posted by Iannucci | 3/10/2009 | 13 comments »
Bookmark and Share

As I noted a few days ago at Silent Pagoda, every year there is a driver who lays claim to the Throne of Injustice, being the obvious recipient of innumerable exclamations of "Why doesn't HE (or SHE) have a ride?" This year that person is Ryan Hunter-Reay, who in addition to his obvious skills has the distinction of being (1) American, (2) personable, and (3) the only driver to have won a race in CART, Champ Car and the IndyCar series. And if Justin Wilson is all set in stone with Dale Coyne, Ryan is also is the only race winner from last year to remain unemployed.

So there is no shortage of reasons to lament his omission from scheduled list of drivers, but none of which really requires that someone *cough*TonyGeorge*cough* step up and open the pocket book to buy the man a ride. Logic dictates if a driver is worth the six meeeeeeellion dollars (or whatever it takes to fund a full season ride) then certainly someone somewhere would see that value any pony up the cash. Consequently, if no one is stepping up then the value for Ryan - or any other unemployed hotshoe - just ain't there.

But perhaps Ryan is a different story. Let's let Robin, no stranger to pounding the podium with his shoe in shock and outrage, make the case for why Ryan may in fact be worth six million.

IZOD is poised to launch one of the largest advertising and promotional campaigns in the Indy Racing League's 14-year history.

Beginning in a few weeks there will be a national television spot, promo trailers in movie theaters, ads in major magazines and newspapers and in-store promotions at Macy's stores across the country that will also include a special Indy 500 clothing line.

It's estimated several million dollars in media value has been budgeted for this project. But there is a little snag in clothing line's plan to take Indy-car racing to the mainstream. No, make that a big snag. The guy they put all the promotion behind, the guy in the TV commercial, the guy in the print ads and the guy on the 90-foot billboard in Times Square doesn't have a ride for the 2009 season.
That guy, as you may have guessed, is Ryan Hunter-Reay.

Now personally, I haven't bought any IZOD products since they closed the Miller's Outpost at the mall back around '89, so my first impression is that this company signed on with Ryan without understanding that his Ethanol-related contract was not renewed for 2009. I believe political wonks call that a failure in vetting.

But, of course, there's still more. A recent interview with Ryan at Desoto Champ Cart Series revealed that this IZOD deal is actually for three years which means someone is seriously committed to putting an IndyCar driver out front and center to the world to see. In trying to recall the last time a driver not named "Danica" was featured in a National ad campaign of any kind I remembered Sarah Fisher in a AAMCO commercial for a year, and before that Tony Kanaan in a Reese's Peanut Butter Cup ad for less than that, and...well, suffice it to say three year-campaigns with IndyCar drivers just don't grow on trees.

And that may prove to be the difference here in whether or not Ryan gets a seat. I don't know where a second car magically appears - the usual suspects are HVM, KV, and of course, Vision Racing - but given all this it certainly appears Hunter-Reay stands an above average chance of racing at St Pete in a few weeks. Then again, if he doesn't make the field, those IZOD people are going to feel more than a little ill.


Photo courtesy of RyanRacing.com

Quote of the day

Posted by Iannucci | 3/09/2009 | 1 comments »
Bookmark and Share

"The pit lane wags wasted no time in nicknaming the trio of NHL cars. We have the 'Mickey D' car, the 'Bobby D' car and, of course, the 'Double D' car. I’ll leave it to you to work out who’s who." - HVM Racing Lead Engineer Michael Cannon, emphasizing the vital importance of proper nicknames in racing.

Is Helio moving to Monaco?

Posted by Iannucci | 3/09/2009 | 7 comments »
Bookmark and Share

There's an AP story out today regarding the Helio Castroneves Tax Trial of the Century that resumes tomorrow, the crux of which is that Helio is being tried for money he never received. That's right - we're talking about paying taxes on the equivalent of an uncashed check. A very large check, the likes of which you or I may never see, but still money (or "monies") left unclaimed.

As Sandwedge points out, this is a bit of a Pandora's Box of a claim to charge someone, basically saying the taxpayer is obligated to pay taxes on money they should have received and not funds of which they actually took possession. The deal here is that Helio was advised (and presumably authorized) to allow for Team Penske to pay a significant portion of earnings to a separate entity, an entity that would hold the money for him for a period of time so that he wouldn't spend it all as foolish young men are often prone to do. In fact, as the defense argues, this is not unlike a 401(k) that you or I might have.

And in the realm of law this seems like a sound basis for a legal argument. Was Helio acting responsibly under advisement in delaying the receipt of these funds or was he attempting to skirt tax laws? That's a fair question for lawyers to sort out, but there's one point the prosecution keeps making that seems entirely nonsensical to me.

Castroneves planned to pay the IRS when the "deferred royalty agreement" - a way of delaying income described as similar to a 401(k) - at Fintage comes due to him in May of this year, defense lawyers say. It's not unusual for athletes to receive some compensation at later dates, they say.

"Athletes ordinarily have a short period of economic productivity in their youth, and they may not be responsible enough to manage the money for a lifetime if they receive it all at once," Bennett said.

(U.S. Attorney Matt) Axelrod, however, said the whole arrangement is fictional, with Castroneves' ultimate goal to move out of the U.S. to a tax haven such as Monaco where he would eventually get the Penske money tax-free.
Alright, hold the phone. I suppose it's entirely conceivable that Helio might one day move to a tax-free nation, but if the taxation on these funds is, as the defense holds, due in May, I'm pretty certain there's no way Helio is going to bail on the opportunity to continue his driving career THIS YEAR and head off to Monaco. I mean, I can say with reasonable certainty based on his projected income that this May he'd be somewhere in Indiana and not across the Atlantic Ocean. And by reasonable I mean 100% chance he'd be at Indianapolis Motor Speedway.

There are other issues in the trial that need to be addressed, including charges of giving false statements to the U.S. government, but if the prosecution agrees that this taxable income was due - at least on paper - this year, then making the argument that Helio was a going to flee the country to claim $5M, while he had so much earning potential ahead of him, seems, well, ridiculous.


In a related note, Paul Page is offering to pass along messages of encouragement to Helio. You can send them to Paul via his own email listed at his blog if you so chose.

Quote of the day

Posted by Iannucci | 3/08/2009 | 6 comments »
Bookmark and Share

But of all of the “transition” drivers from 2008, the guy I’m really looking forward to watching in ’09 is EJ Viso. He has the chance to be a mega-star. - Mike King, Voice of IMS Radio, who like so many of us has already begun consuming copious amounts of Visoberry Power Juice.

ADDENDUM: Listen to King deftly screaming with excitement throughout the promo for the upcoming "Ten Ten Closest Finishes" special on VERSUS this Saturday.

Searching for Helio news

Posted by Iannucci | 3/06/2009 | 2 comments »
Bookmark and Share

As maddening as the length of the offseason has been, the content filling up the spaces in between hasn't been overly encouraging. We've endured bad economic news relating to team downsizing, driver unemployment rising, and even the loss of a race in Detroit, but no news has weighed more heavily on fans than the pending tax evasion trial of Helio Castroneves.

For those who weren't aware, Helio's trial started this week with jury selection and opening arguments. The trial is expected to last four to six weeks, which means Team Penske has already said Will Power will represent at the opening event at St Petersburg. I guess that's an early victory for the prosecution.

But beyond that there hasn't been much news, at least not proportionate to other celebrity trials. Maybe law experts are hesitant to comment on a tax case. Maybe Helio isn't exactly a prolific celebrity. Maybe with the 90-plus-percent conviction rate on Federal cases Helio's goose is already cooked. But even with all of that there still should be some reporting of court proceedings.

Well, your humble host has decided to dig around and see what could be found, and after countless milliseconds of Google searches I've managed to discover a handful of links. It's not much, but hopefully there's something you did not know will be included in this overly long post.

The best place to start is an article from late last year from Car and Driver that indicates much of what is being built in this case originates from a conflict Helio had with another two-time winner of the Indianapolis 500.

On June 11, 1997, another Brazilian, ex-driver Emerson Fittipaldi, then 50, a two-time Formula 1 champion and twice Indy 500 champion, had signed a five-year contract to manage Castroneves. A little over two years later, Castroneves fired Fittipaldi, several days after his then-team owner, the late Carl Hogan, announced he was folding Hogan Racing on October 28, 1999.

Less than a week later, Castroneves signed a three-year deal with Roger Penske for $2 million per year, negotiated by the motorsports über-lawyer Alan R. Miller, to create one of the most enduring partnerships in modern racing.

Fittipaldi was not pleased, and in February 2000, he sued for $3.3 million, claiming breach of contract. The case was finally heard in 2004, fought over by some of Miami’s legal super heavyweights. A jury did not award financial damages to either Brazilian. Fittipaldi appealed all the way to the Florida Supreme Court, where he lost and was ordered to pay $60,000 for Castroneves’ appellate legal fees...Five of the seven counts allege the crimes continued until the last day of the Fittipaldi civil trial, while several exhibits in current filings were lifted from that case.
Which brings us to the actual list of indictments themselves. What seems to be at the core of the case is two companies, Seven Promotions and Fintage Licensing, that may or may not be legal entities.

It appears Seven Promotions is based in Panama, but is run by Helio's dad, who reportedly helped garner financing for much of Helio's early career. During opening arguments the prosecution said Helio - not his father - ran this entity, but I don't know how critical that presumption is to the case. (Paging Roger Cossack...)

According to the indictment, Helio and his advisors were reluctant at Team Penske's insistence at withholding 30% of his paycheck to be deposited in a Seven Promotions account, so that's where Fintage Licensing comes to be. From the Department of Justice.

The indictment specifically alleges that Helio Castroneves, Katiucia Castroneves and Miller engaged in a scheme to avoid paying taxes on the $5,000,000 in licensing agreement income by creating a “deferred royalty plan” that required Penske to send the $5,000,000 payment to an offshore company – Fintage Licensing B.V. (Fintage) – in the Netherlands, instead of to Seven Promotions.

Despite advice from outside tax counsel that Helio Castroneves would not qualify for the deferred royalty plan and would owe income tax on all payments under the licensing agreement if he or any member of his family owned or controlled Seven Promotions, the three defendants engaged in this deferred royalty plan.
So another issue being discussed in court will no doubt be the legality of Fintage and the tax liabilities that have resulted from depositing money there.

Now, this Alan Miller guy is apparently very will known in racing and is highly thought of outside of this trial. He also represents Jimmie Johnson, Martin Truex Jr, and Clint Bowyer, some of whom may be called to testify during the trial. Additionally Roger Penske and Juan Pablo Montoya may appear as well.

Will at is it May yet? has a partial list of declared witnesses, as well as some great pics from Helio's early days. (Hey Will, if you're reading this, quit messing around with NASA and get back to updating your site. And thanks for allowing the unauthorized use of one of your graphics in this post.)

Coincidentally Miller also reportedly represents Danica Patrick, who is auditing her own financial paperwork as we speak. I tried to garner some meaningful information on Miller in an SI.com article by Tim Tuttle but all I got was "He's a good friend. We've eaten sushi together in three countries." Thanks, Tim.

So after all of this searching it appears there's exactly one place that's offering any kind of meaningful news and analysis relating to the trial: accountingweb.com. Bookmark this link and check back daily, as they appear to be offering some semblance of insight into the direction of the trial. Score one for the accountants.

There's also one last place you can check and that's Helio's personal blog. It does have some fun pics of him and his nephew, but for the most part it doesn't seem to be updated much. Then again, that seems to be the case nearly everywhere else.

UPDATE: Will has indeed answered the call, finding more possibly distressing news for everyone's favorite fence climber.

Well, the prosecution is arguing that some of the potentially funneled money wasn’t only ducking taxes in this country, but also in Helio’s homeland of Brazil. Currently, there’s debate between the prosecution and defense over whether this is pertinent to the case at hand and whether an expert on the Brazilian Tax Code should be allowed to testify.

(MORE at is it May yet?)

New VERSUS promo to fire you up

Posted by Iannucci | 3/05/2009 | 19 comments »
Bookmark and Share

Perhaps it's a touch heavy on crashes, but otherwise I'll defer to the immortal words of Helio Castroneves: "Now that is what I am talking about!"



Now all we have to do is wait another month and we'll be set.

(Thanks to Vision Racing for posting this 30 seconds of AWESOMENESS.)

Quote of the day

Posted by Iannucci | 3/05/2009 | 4 comments »
Bookmark and Share

"We're going to be starting our coverage in March with four one-hour specials, and windows for the races, which used to be two hours, will be three hours. You'll see prerace, postrace, and the night before there will be a one-hour preview with pole qualifiers and everything that happened the week before. We're going to do seven hours a week every week. That's the most that's ever been done." - Jamie Davis, President of VERSUS, instructing you all to free up some space in your DVR immediately.

Danica wants to kick my ass

Posted by Iannucci | 3/04/2009 | 18 comments »
Bookmark and Share

I know I take issue with Mrs Hospenthal on occasion, but really, I swear, I don't hate the woman. Nothing could be further from the truth. I don't have any "Danica" merchandise on me (although my oldest daughter does), but despite my concern with certain choices she makes I'm no less a fan of hers than any other driver.

Really. I mean it. Stop laughing.

Hey, if I didn't have a soft spot in my heart for her would I have read the entire My-husband-Paul-is-sooooo-schmoopy tome that is "Crossing the Line"? Would I have written about how ridiculously unfair the comparison to Anna Kournikova was? Would I have shamelessly planted my kids outside of a restroom just to get her autograph?

Of course not - Danica and I are cool. At least, that's what I thought. But now I find out she wants to kick my ass, and even worse, she wants to kick yours as well. Gird your hindquarters accordingly.



I sincerely look forward to the exceptionally civil discourse regarding this promo that will be conducted in the "comments" of this post.

UPDATE: For a chuckle or two, be sure to check out the Danica roasting at pressdog and Diecast Dude. Or, to put it another way, feel free to momentarily expand the Great Danica Flame Wars of '09 to a different battlefield.